The Illusion of Band 9.0The other day, while searching for reliable IELTS speaking sample answers, I stumbled across a fellow instructor's Telegram channel. They boldly claimed Band 9.0 performances for their own responses. Intrigued, I started listening. While their responses had some value for the average student, I was shocked at how many inaccuracies and mistakes I could easily spot. This raises an important question:
"How much trust should we place in a candidate’s self-assessment?"
(yes, even when that candidate is your teacher? Sadly, it has become common to celebrate a handful of our success stories (7.0 or above) while conveniently ignoring the less-than-stellar outcomes (anything short of 7.0). These days another worrying trend is emerging: teachers boldly proclaiming Band 9.0 scores
for their essays/speaking answers to attract followers to their blogs and boost to their reputation.
Let's agree that most of these teachers
have already proven their command of English, earning impressive Band 8.5 or 9.0 for different components of the IELTS exam. Their expertise is real, but such actions do little to set a good example for students. Claiming perfection in every response leads to many missed opportunities for learning, both for the instructors concerned and their students/followers.
True growth - whether in language or life - starts with humility. A willingness to admit that even your "best" work can be improved opens the door to meaningful insights. It encourages curiosity about the nuances of language and the broader world. Instead of projecting infallibility, teachers should model the mindset of continuous learning, showing students that excellence is a journey, not a final destination.
So, what’s the solution? Honesty and modesty. Instead of claiming that your work deserves a Band 9.0 (and betting your life on it), try something more grounded: "This is a Band 7.0+ or 8.0+ response" (based on your consistent exam results. This builds credibility but also sets an good example for students.
@dilmurod_nazarmatov